Here are my thoughts on each of the short listed candidates for the Polaris prize to be given out on Monday night (September 21 at 8:00EST). I’ll warn you and apologize in advance, this post is going to be a the lengthy side.
—
Elliot Brood – Mountain Meadows
There are some really great tracks on this record like Write It All Down For You and the Valley Town but there are also several mediocre tracks and I felt like the album, great title aside, was generally a little uninspired and definitely not deserving to win. I just want to stress that I am not saying this is a bad record, but the winner of the Polaris prize should be a record that is an outstanding musical achievement and Elliot Brood does not reach that level.
Fucked Up – The Chemistry of Common Life
This record on the other hand was bad, very bad in fact. Normally I try to listen to things a couple times or at least listen to a few songs more than once, but I was grateful when I realized that I had made it through all ten tracks of the Chemistry of Common Life and would never half to listen to them again. Many journalists/bloggers/people in general have predicted that, the quality of the album aside (they were short-listed so someone likes them), the band’s name will prevent them from winning the Polaris. Although I agree that their name will likely prevent them from breaking into the mainstream in a big way, I don’t think the journalists and members of the music community are going to balk at the name in terms of voting for them. I hate to write reviews that are so negative, but I guess it comes with reviewing a bunch of albums chosen by someone else. If there is one good thing I can say about this record, it is that some tracks have a sense of urgency to them that makes me think they would be better live than in studio.
Great Lake Swimmers – Lost Channels
First listen through and my overall impression is that this is a very pretty record but I need to listen to it again before I can evaluate it on a less superficial level. Second listen through proved that although the record is pretty, it is generally boring. This is the kind of record that is great to study to because it is very minimally distracting. When I listen to the songs attentively, I like them and I get the impression that this band listened to extensively over time could become a band I severely doubt that they will win a Polaris with this album. If you want to check out Great Lake Swimmers, I recommend listening to Concrete Heart which has excellent violin and keyboard tracks and reminds me a lot of Wilco as well as The Chorus in the Underground which has an endearing country twang to it.
Hey Rosetta – Into Your Lungs
I actually picked up this album two or three days after my original post where I planned to review all the Polaris albums. When I turned the album over to make sure it was the band I thought it was and saw that the record was produced by Hawksley Workman, I definitely had to buy it. You may be wondering why, in all this time, I have not bothered to post a review of it. To be honest, I am not entirely sure but I think it came down to me being so entirely torn on how I feel about this album. I really love Hawksley and on some tracks I am positive I can hear him singing (although there is no mention of him providing vocals in the liner notes) and some of the tracks on this record are amazing. I really like I’ve Been Asleep for a Long Time and their single on the radio, Red Heart, (not to be confused with Black Heart). However, after that song the album goes completely downhill. Since I had the actual CD, I had been listening to it on random for about week before I noticed that the entire second half of the album is boring. Really, really boring – if Hey Rosetta had made the second half of the album on par with the first they would have been a serious contender for the Polaris, but in actuality I am surprised they made it to the short list.
K’Naan – Troubadour
I really did not know what to expect when I started listening to this album, I am not generally a fan of rap but I have been following K’Naan for some time on Twitter and I have been amused and pleased at how down to earth he is as well as how connected he is to his fans. My favourite song on this record is Dreamer, I love the lyrics in the chorus and the song is just fun to listen to. That actually goes for the whole record; K’Naan definitely does not sing about the easiest or most upbeat topics as he draws a lot of inspiration from growing up in Wardhiigleey, a gang infested district of Mogadishu and lived there during the Somali Civil War regardless listening to his record, you get the impression that he is hopeful about the world and that he was having fun when he was creating this record. One of my favourite lyrics from the record is “My job is to write what I see/So a visual stenographer is what I be” from I Come Prepared.
Malajube – Labrinthes
First of all, I have to own up to the fact that there is a significant lost in translation issue with French bands for me; one of the major aspects that drive my appreciation of music are lyrics and that is totally nonexistent with Malajube. Not that they don’t have lyrics, but that my understanding of them is little to none. With that being the case, all I will say about them is that I loved that one of the songs was called Porté Disaparu which I am fairly certain means ‘disappearing door’ and I really like Dragon De Glace.
Metric – Fantasies
Three of the songs on this record are very popular radio singles, they are all decent songs but way overplayed. Moreover, Metric was in a sense ruined for me a few years ago when I left one of their shows in a rage because their fan base seems to mainly consist of fifteen year old girls who love to scream through a band’s entire set. Neither of these things is Metric’s fault, however I know I am not the only person who has had enough of them being included among the ranks of Canadian indie darlings. There are good tracks on this album like Satellite Minda and Gold Guns Girls but there are also songs like Twilight Galaxy which make me feel like Metric has been writing the same song for years about people telling Emily Haines how to behave and her complaining about the downside of fame, “did I ask you for attention when affection is what I need”. Fantasies is not a Polaris winning album, but I think that their mainstream popularity puts them completely out of the race. The majority of the people who are voting are people who want to see this money go to a band who needs it, Metric is not that band.
Joel Plaskett – Three
Setting out on the odyssey that is Joel Plaskett’s latest album, a triple disc 27 track epic, I find myself wondering why I didn’t write the review for this one when I bought it months ago. In all actuality, listening to it is a labour of love and I could easily write this review without listening to the record again. There are so many great songs on this album, and Plaskett is a lyrical genius. On Through & Through & Through he sings, “I’m the Berlin Wall/ I’m a Communist/You’re a wrecking ball/In a summer dress” actually, every lyric in this song is pretty awesome. I love the whole concept behind this album, three cds with 9 songs each and many of the song titles are the same word repeated three times. This is Plaskett’s second nomination (he also received a nod for 2007’s Ashtray Rock) and I am not sure if that will work for or against him. I would love to see Plaskett win – he has been on of my favourite artists for a long time, he has been a mainstay in the Canadian indie scene for almost two decades now and this is a kickass record. Unfortuantely, the same argument that applied to Metric applies to him – he is pretty mainstream now, he was even in a Zellers commercial (funny enough, Emily Haines shot one of the videos for her solo project in a Zellers) and he definitely has no need for the money or the exposure.
Chad VanGaalen – Soft Airplane
This is it! Seriously, as much as I love Joel Plaskett – this is a formidable record. Every song is awesome, great lyrics and a cool sound. From Bones of Man, “I felt at peace and alive/Even though the ship was going down”. Lyrically they remind me of the Decemberists because every song tells a fantastic and whimsical story. The record really varies in sound too, moving from the pretty and serene Cries of the Dead to Old Man + the Sea which sounds like it was performed by Neil Young and then to the erratic electronica that closes out the album in Frozen Energon.
Patrick Watson – Wooden Arms
I feel like I am having the same problem with a lot of these records, that although there are a few strong tracks they are rounded out with relatively uninteresting ones. With Patrick Watson’s third effort pales in comparison the (Polaris winning) 2006 release, Close to Paradise. Highlights on this album are the piano track that starts Beijing and the male/female combination on vocals on Big Bird in a Small Cage. The combination of having won previously plus a relatively lackluster record puts them out of the running for this year’s prize.
—
If I was voting: Joel Plaskett – Three, runnerup Chad VanGaalen – Soft Airplane
My Predictions:
1. Chad VanGaalen
2. Joel Plaskett
3. K’Naan – yup, he is sort of in the wrong genre, but he has put out a truly excellent record and I think he is the wild card in the short list.
Tune in tomorrow night at 8pm to CBC Radio 3 who will be broadcasting the whole event live. I think they are announcing the winner around 9:30.